Need help choosing: ATS vs Godrej in Noida?

ATS Green or Godrej Palm Retreat? I'm confused. Need at least a 3BHK for the kids. My wife's priority is a safe neighbourhood. Dekho, ATS ka reputation toh acha hai, but I've heard stories about possession delays. Is it still a problem? Godrej seems promising, but slightly smaller flats for the same price. The carpet area advertised and actual carpet area ka kya scene hai? Anyone faced hidden charges with either of them, like extra PLC at the time of possession? Which one gives better resale value, say 5 years down the line, if I ever need to move? Honestly not sure which way to go. Koi experience share karo please.